Vendor reports are biased. Analyst reports are detached. This is the first framework built by practitioners who actually run communities. It covers 9 feature categories across 14 platforms. Use it to figure out what you actually need and stop getting sold features you'll never use.
Mark each feature as must-have, important, nice-to-have, or not needed.
Click the minimum acceptable standard for each feature.
Download your requirements as a .xlsx you can drop straight into an RFP.
Pick one, or pick several. When you pick multiple, each feature defaults to the highest priority and minimum level across the models you selected. Tweak from there. Read more about the five models.
This isn't a comprehensive list. You'll also want to cover integrations, support, data privacy, and security requirements separately. But it does cover the critical functionality requirements.